Then, use the New York Times online to search for the title of the play. You'll get a lot of results!
Use the "Date Range" function on the left-hand side of the results page to limit your result to the specific year that the play was premiered in New York. That way, you'll find reviews of the original production, not any newer revivals.
Scholarly articles in literature and linguistics, including books, essay collections, conference proceedings, dissertations, and bibliographies. Dates: 1926-present.